BitTorrent : Saviour or Devel's Spawn?

The RIAA and Comcast would have you believe that BitTorrent and it's ilk are the bane of copyright holders everywhere. So is there really a good argument which would legitimize this service? Or, is BitTorrent just a delivery method for pirated softwa

Posted By codeninja on September 11, 2007

You can subscribe to this Debate if you log in.

About codeninja

Top Enemies: Cyclops
Jake

Profit loss to piracy is a straw-man defense based not in reality, but i...

Posted By Jake_the_Mad on September 12, 2007

Rails_logo

BitTorrent was written and designed to distribute free software.

Posted By testuser on September 11, 2007

Call For Backup

Invite others to join and support you in this debate. Or maybe you just want to pick a fight! Either way...

Call for backup now!

Bit Torrent has many legitimate uses

Jake

Profit loss to piracy is a straw-man defense based not in reality, but in desire.

-- Posted By Jake_the_Mad on September 12, 2007

Can people lose money to pirates? Sure. Do they? Not per the statistics gathered by the University of Minnesota's department of economic research!. Interestingly, more than 60% of the people who illegally download music, as per this two year study, went on to purchase it within the next 3-6 months. The margin was slightly less, but still over half, for more expensive software. Now, let's contrast this against another market commodity of significant value; exposure and product familiarity. If 1,000,000 people download your product illegally and 500,000 buy it as a result, you're better off than if only. 250,000 people had purchased it without that exposure. And don't think the savvy software firms are dumb to this. They'd rather have you pirating their software than a competitor's, for example. Why?. Because you are far more likely to buy what you're familiar with! The RIAA is just too dumb to flex with the changing times, plainly put...but I guarantee you that big software producers like Microsoft and Adobe aren't. But, go check it out for yourself. Microsoft and Adobe have both made a lot of their priorly protected products available for commendably long trial-period downloads, and that's only the beginning. Even game producers are starting to get wise to the reality of turning piracy into profit; look at all the demos available now and compare that to how many were available 5 years ago. Big difference, eh? Expect the brilliant marketers in the wor. to capitalize further on making good on the exposure and familiarity piracy hands them for free. Expect also for monkey businesses like the RIAA to have many more panic attacks before going the way of the dinosaur.

Rails_logo

BitTorrent was written and designed to distribute free software.

-- Posted By testuser on September 11, 2007

Bittorrent is by far the best and fastest way to distribute free software such as Linux ISO's. In fact, bittorrent helps support the open source community by offloading bandwidth from project servers onto those who are downloading software, saving these projects significant amounts of money.

BitTorrent is nothing more than a delivery method for Infringement

Rss RSS