Is McCain just completely confused, or does he know what he's doing?

Senator John Kerry Says that John McCain is confused and "unbelievably out of touch." What do you think?

Reference: http://www.politico.com/blogs/bensmith/0608/Kerry_McCain_confused_unbelievably_out_of_touch.html

Posted By deepdope on June 11, 2008

You can subscribe to this Debate if you log in.

About deepdope

"It's like a finger.. Pointing to the moon." Hey, Bruce Lee said it. Not me.

Mosquito

McCain is not Perfect but

Posted By ajouie53 on July 22, 2008

Phplwvt0m_c1am

Mc Cain's education plan

Posted By Alicia on June 12, 2008

Person_60

Voter Power: Do what is right!

Posted By AudraSG on June 17, 2008

Pooja_diya

A true leader

Posted By bharathganesh on June 13, 2008

Call For Backup

Invite others to join and support you in this debate. Or maybe you just want to pick a fight! Either way...

Call for backup now!

McCain is a confused old man

Karl_marx

"cash rules everything around me" -wutang-

-- Posted By Jarod on June 12, 2008

his economic policy is a joke. if tax breaks for the rich and more war to feed armament corporations is his best plan for pulling us out of recession then we will really be in trouble. besides, i dont know if anyone remembers the keating 5 scandal but although he wasnt censured, he was criticized for shady behavior. to me, that implies that his economic motivations will more than likely be ulterior. not to mention beneficial to him or the people who hand him money. and the last thing we need sitting in office is a hard headed jock with a handful of missiles. i cant vouch for obama but i am ready for change.

Top Comments

im not sure if "hard headed jock" is the term i would use. he definitely had some impressive feats during his service in the military. but a fighter is definitely not what we need right now. aside from that, his questionable political agenda is a definite deal breaker for me.
i researched the keating 5 scandal and although he wasnt directly censured there is still evidence of his involvement or at least knowledge of the corruption. this shows that he was willing to be dishonest for the sake of money. id rather have an honest newbie in office than a battle hardened veteran with war and dollar signs in his eyes.
McCain received more campaign contributions than any of the other 4 that were implicated in the Keating 5 scandal. The whole deal cost tax payers billions of dollars. sounds like he great guy...
Add Comment Show all 7 comments
Luigi2

Confused old man is the least of his problems

-- Posted By Luigi on June 11, 2008

Calling him confused, or old, really overlooks John McCain's biggest drawback, which is that he will continue the disasterous policies of George W. Bush for another four years, and Americans can't afford that.

Can you believe that in this time of rising gas prices, John McCain wants to give even more tax breaks to big oil companies? Out of OUR tax money, no less! He also wants to continue the tax breaks for the wealthy - tax breaks that he opposed when he wasn't running for President - and he has no coherent economic plan to lead us out of recession.

Second, he'll continue this terrible war in Iraq for, as he say, "100 years". He is also itching to attack Iran and his ugly warmongering should scare any sane American.

He claims to be a Maverick but it's just more of the same - more economic policies that reward big business and the rich while crushing the middle class, more war, more incompetent leadership. We can't afford another term of George Bush. I'm voting Obama.

Top Comments

Great article I 100% agree. Hopefully we can pull this one out in November. Hopefully the republicans don't cheat again this time.
You are so right. We do not need a watch the rich get richer while the strugglers get buried kind of ethic in office.
I don't think any of us can say McCain will be another Bush term because that would imply that he has outlined his policies if he were President and we were able to compare them to Bush and say- yes, this is more of the same. McCain (and all the other candidates for that matter) has done nothing of the sort. So much of this presidential campaign has been mudslinging and a race for popularity that no one seems to be outlining position and policy. Let's hope in the coming weeks McCain shows all voters what he stands for in no uncertain terms. If he does, maybe the other candidates will take notice that substance matters to all voters, regardless or party affiliation. Until then it just seems to be a beauty contest which is sad and demeaning to think that's all Americans want for their leader.
Add Comment Show all 7 comments
Golem

McCain had to sell his soul to be here

-- Posted By golem on June 12, 2008

McCain had to sell his soul to the darkest forces of his party to be supported up to this point. He was a decent person (for a republican...) but then, to obtain the money to go, he had to embrace new causes with new enthusiasm... if American elect him, he had to pay a lot of debts to those who pushed him. We will see more war (which means more money for those who build armaments) and we will see more favors made to the oil companies... Do you think thats' OK? I do not think that being old is the worst problem, but certainly there are a lot of people that when old do whatever to preserve their power. They simply do not accept that age has effect.

Top Comments

I agree, McCain's current platform is a lot more extreme than the views he used to express ten or twenty years ago. I don't know if he sold his soul or just got more conservative with age (it happens...).
macain ....an old horse
macain may be having an experience of american politics but he seems to be definate successor of bush who by his policies has made US lookdown at most of the fields.Macain by hisview has created a trouble for himself n will face a hard competetion by barack who has come like a prophet to modern America
yes, a lot of republicans are skeptical of McCain because of his shifting positions
Add Comment Show all 4 comments
Img_3820

4 More Years (or horribly more) With Bush Policy?

-- Posted By lizzy on June 12, 2008

I absolutely agree with this. Our country cannot afford another leader along the lines of GWB! Just look where we sit today, high gas prices, sinking housing market, poor economy, poorly performing stock market - and we're still in Iraq. Please we can't afford to have McCain win this election.

True about GWB, but unlike Shrubby Jr, McCain actually went to war and didn't try to squirrel out of it.
Add Comment
Alcoholic_afraid_of_life

McCain is a horrible choice for America

-- Posted By dealtwith on June 11, 2008

I'm not saying that Obama will be any different, but McCain will be just more of the same.

Just stating my case. Obama needs experience governing before he is ready to be President.
I believe that Obama can make a big differance, a positive one, for USA
pointless statement...
Add Comment
Person_60

Mccain fails in economic policy

-- Posted By zodi on June 11, 2008

McCain fails his economic policy because he said spent more money for war. But this is not good for our economy. An independent source says This war is more important than a new highway overpass, a pig farm or a peanut barn. And most Americans, whether they support or oppose the war, expect their representatives to cast an honest vote on whether to fund it, and not use it as another excuse to waste their money. But it does not required now.

peanut farm? what are you talking about? McCain isnt the reason we are in iraq right now and its a little too late to just pack up and leave immediately. he wants to tie up loose ends over there. and of course it will cost money.
Add Comment
Salt

John McCain would be Bush All Over Again

-- Posted By jessetoast on June 11, 2008

As the final election approaches, many people are wondering why or why not John McCain would make a good president or not. It is EXTREMELY obvious what the answer to that question is. John McCain would make a terrible president for many reasons, and not just because he is old. He has horrible ideas: as Luigi says, he wants to give more money to oil companies by making us pay, he wants to STAY in Iraq. He has horrible ideas on development and the environment. I think that he would nearly be Bush all over again. Obama would be such a better candidate and McCain would ruin this country even more than how terrible it is now.

Given McCain's recent pronouncements, it would seem as if he's seriously considering "a future where the U.S. 'does not pla[y] a combat role' in Iraq by 2013."


http://blog.wired.com/defense/2008/05/mccain-obama-no.html
Add Comment
Person_60

Mccain fails in economic policy

-- Posted By zodi on June 11, 2008

McCain fails his economic policy because he said spent more money for war. But this is not good for our economy. An independent source says This war is more important than a new highway overpass, a pig farm or a peanut barn. And most Americans, whether they support or oppose the war, expect their representatives to cast an honest vote on whether to fund it, and not use it as another excuse to waste their money. But it does not required now.

Angryasian2

John Kerry is right

-- Posted By iwantms on June 17, 2008

McCain is clueless

Person_60

Voter Power: Do what is right!

-- Posted By AudraSG on June 17, 2008

I encourage the general public to educate themselves on the issues before jumping to conclusions or accepting another person's opinion as their own. This is perhaps the most critical election of all time. Truly think about the mess this country is in and the future of your children... We need a strong leader that understands both sides of the ticket. McCain used to be a democrat and realized the faults of the party. While he is now a republican, he still adheres to the liberal mind set where their policies are working. He is also intelligent enough to adopt the conservative policies that will guide and benefit the future of this country. The moral of the story is: Do NOT be brainwashed by your political affiliation. A good president is one who can fully appreciate both sides of the story, who can adopt the best policies accordingly (regardless of political affiliation) and provide pull through and consistency. McCain is the man for the job! No matter how you look at it, Obama does not have the experience nor the tenure just yet to be the next leader of the free world. Do the right thing and vote based on intelligent decisions - not because you are brain washed by your party of choice. God Bless America!

Alaurahospcloseupbnw

Go Ahead Talk 'cause I'm Done Listening!

-- Posted By Simplyme on June 11, 2008

With all the media surrounding elections these days you would think a real winner wouldn't be riding it out on the waves of everyone else. People are sitting around waiting to hear how he is going to help the people and what do they hear?...nothing. Well, that shows you exactly what to expect of him politically...nothing. Well that may be an exaggeration because it appears he would show us how many more ways there are to part with more of our hard earned money. Am I wrong? We will never know because by the time he starts talking we will all be done listening.

there,s not need to do all that yapping let the record speak for itself,when your in your basement dodging missles you'll think better.
your comment is just as ignorant, struggler.
Add Comment
Rhon

We Can't Afford McSame

-- Posted By luvdemfins on June 17, 2008

After 8 years of the Bush Administartion this country cannot afford 4 more years with John McCain who until recently has been a clone of G.W. We need a positive change in America we are in a recession, at war, distrusted and disliked around the globe and I am not so sure about Obama but I am sure that John McCain is not the answer. Most Americans have been like sheep where the Bush Administartion is concerned and I am fearful that they will continue to be so with McCain, (no one is as blind as those who will not see)I belive that we are in a crisis and this surpasses party lines and we need to forget party affiliations and start acting like ONE we share a commonality as we are all AMERICANS and when we hurt we hurt as Americans not as Dems or Republicans. Change is at least what Obama is offering and change can be good, McCain is offering more of the same.

Gracie

We can't keep doing this to ourselves with weak politicians

-- Posted By jaja75 on August 7, 2008

George Bush won fair and square (allegedly) in 2004 with the help of fear mongering and patriotic themes...he has done nothing short of run this country into the ground, erode freedom and cheat americans out of their quality of life...I said this in 2004 to everyone, and was shown the door.

Obama is far from perfect, and his resume isn't as thick as some of the others, this is true...But I really think given the chance, he would be a good leader, and America could start to heal.

Religion is irrelevant, he isn't running for pope.

Mccains negative campaigning and sad attempts at humor are horrible and ridiculous. In a time where america is begging for strength, leadership and integrity, he seems to offer lame jokes and even lamer attacks. I am so frustrated with this tactic.
Add Comment

McCain knows what he's doing, and can think for himself

Myimage

Experience makes a difference

-- Posted By phmcd10 on June 11, 2008

What this country needs is leadership and John McCain is the most experienced person running for the job. I believe this country needs change but change does not always mean a change in parties.

Top Comments

Actually, tax breaks for oil companies as well as for the rich will boost investment demand. His health care plan that is rooted in the belief of competition is the only thing that will salve broken health care system.
Experience ? You do not really need experience, you need a staff with cojones and the honesty to follow their advice. I think McCain is too proud to follow reasonable advices, unless they come from those who paid his campaign...
Well said phmcd. I completely go by your views.
Add Comment Show all 10 comments
Thinker

LIKE VINTAGE WINE

-- Posted By struggler on June 11, 2008

John McCain has a illustrious military career that says he's the right man for the job I don't have anything against obama ,but i would feel a lot safer sleeping at night with Mr. mc cain at the helm,plus you can't go through what he went threw during the war years and not have a tough as nails dexterity, and that is just what we neeg.

Update:
John McCain has a illustrious military career that says he's the right man for the job I don't have anything against obama ,but i would feel a lot safer sleeping at night with Mr. mc cain at the helm,plus you can't go through what he went threw during the war years and not have a tough as nails dexterity, and that is just what we need.
I have to disagree with you, I come from a long line of military people my Father was in 3 wars served 30 years, Yes that does show character but my disagreement is the fact that it will make a good President. When it comes to economic policy McCain is off the mark. Many people say Obama has no experience well Bush had experience and now so do we. We are experienced in "losing" our homes, our jobs, our respect around the world, our soldiers lives, our savings, and I could go on and on about the cost of G.W.'s experience. Maybe that is what we need a person at the helm instead of a polished politician who will tell us what we want to hear and then do as they please when they get in office. Make no mistakes about it McCain is a politician and he shares a lot of the same ideas as Bush even though recently he has tried to distance himself. As for feeling safer at night I want someone who will use diplomacy instead of artillary.
well said, luvdemfins
Very well said...
Add Comment
Picture1