Death cannot possibly be balanced by more death
Killing someone who has done terrible things will never undo those terrible things. It wont bring back loved ones. All it does is take away the chance for that person to change their life and seek redemption.
Logically, how much sense does it make to have very strict laws on murder, yet thats exactly what the punishment is for certain degrees of the crime?
I can't support the idea that the state has the right to murder whomever they see fit, regardless of the reason. Plus, I subscribe to the Consistent Life Ethic.
The death penalty does not bring justice, but rather satisfies a need for vengeance by the victim's family and society in general. In many cases, those on death row committed heinous crimes, because it would result in the state putting them to death. You can never be certain of a person's guilt and once an individual is executed, the state has no hope of ever making the situation right.
Some people do not deserve to live
If they ended someones life then why should they have the right to continue living? It should be automatically forfeit. What else would you have them do with such scum? Use your taxes to feed them for decades until they rot away in prison?
I agree that some people should not be allowed to live.
Perhaps we should have let the recently hanged dictator live and maybe he would have redeemed himself. How long might it have taken? A year, two years, maybe even a little longer.
What is the alternative? Death or Imprisonment. That is a great question. I did think about the classic film and lobotomize them. But, there would need to be somebody to look after them and that would have to come out of the taxpayers money. And, the victims family would be paying that inadvertently.
I can't help thinking that if I were in the situation of having my child, or a loved one, murdered, would hanging, lethal injection or electric chair be enough. I know it is emotional revenge, but I would want them put to suffering the pain of death.
Over here in the UK we had a nurse that systematically murdered defenceless babies. Should she be allowed to live? Well she is enjoying rent-free accommodation where all her meals are provided for her (see link below). Is this right? I say not.

Digg
Delicious
Reddit
Yahoo
Google
Stumbleupon

RSS
About Jarod