Is there really justice in the death penalty?

there are people in this world that have committed unspeakable crimes. is death the only justice? or is there room for redemption?

Posted By Jarod on January 14, 2008

You can subscribe to this Debate if you log in.
Jerome

One Flew Over The Cuckoos Nest

Posted By Jerome on April 25, 2008

L_684f116ceb600ffaf044e0afa7831b0f

Its barbaric and hypocritical

Posted By jhall85 on January 18, 2008

Gimbi_vex

It's simple

Posted By jrg6381 on July 18, 2008

Sauron

When has death ever been the answer?

Posted By Murphy810 on January 18, 2008

Call For Backup

Invite others to join and support you in this debate. Or maybe you just want to pick a fight! Either way...

Call for backup now!

Death cannot possibly be balanced by more death

Sauron

When has death ever been the answer?

-- Posted By Murphy810 on January 18, 2008

Killing someone who has done terrible things will never undo those terrible things. It wont bring back loved ones. All it does is take away the chance for that person to change their life and seek redemption.

L_684f116ceb600ffaf044e0afa7831b0f

Its barbaric and hypocritical

-- Posted By jhall85 on January 18, 2008

Logically, how much sense does it make to have very strict laws on murder, yet thats exactly what the punishment is for certain degrees of the crime?

Gimbi_vex

It's simple

-- Posted By jrg6381 on July 18, 2008

I can't support the idea that the state has the right to murder whomever they see fit, regardless of the reason. Plus, I subscribe to the Consistent Life Ethic.

If you think about it, what's worse? Being executed, or having to sit in a jail cell for the rest of your life? Seems to me it's far more just to take away the perpetrator's freedoms...the same ones that were taken away from the victim. No more fresh air, no more walks in the country, no more family vacations, no more Chinese take-out, no more opening night at the movies...no more anything except gray walls and prison food. It is a more fit punishment to confine rather than execute, I believe.
Add Comment
05_juneau_076

Simple Vengeance

-- Posted By shullrd on October 6, 2008

The death penalty does not bring justice, but rather satisfies a need for vengeance by the victim's family and society in general. In many cases, those on death row committed heinous crimes, because it would result in the state putting them to death. You can never be certain of a person's guilt and once an individual is executed, the state has no hope of ever making the situation right.

Some people do not deserve to live

Person_60

Why should they have the right to redeem themselves?

-- Posted By ramrod on January 18, 2008

If they ended someones life then why should they have the right to continue living? It should be automatically forfeit. What else would you have them do with such scum? Use your taxes to feed them for decades until they rot away in prison?

i am against killing people, even those who commited unspeakable crimes (example: a man who took a 2 year old boy and threw him off the overpass onto the freeway, killing him). there has to be some other way to deal with these people. as murphy810 said, death is not the answer. on the other hand, as ramrod said, why should the taxpayers have to pay to house and feed these criminals?? is there an alternative to kiling them or putting them in jail?
The death penalty is appropriate for those classes of criminals who are insatiable killers, pedophiles, and rapists and for whom escape or parole is always an option to return them to prey on society because do-gooders are always looking for ways to release them and prison wardens dump them on the street to cut costs. (See earlier question on this site about releasing thousands of hardened criminals.
Add Comment
Jerome

One Flew Over The Cuckoos Nest

-- Posted By Jerome on April 25, 2008

I agree that some people should not be allowed to live.

Perhaps we should have let the recently hanged dictator live and maybe he would have redeemed himself. How long might it have taken? A year, two years, maybe even a little longer.

What is the alternative? Death or Imprisonment. That is a great question. I did think about the classic film and lobotomize them. But, there would need to be somebody to look after them and that would have to come out of the taxpayers money. And, the victims family would be paying that inadvertently.

I can't help thinking that if I were in the situation of having my child, or a loved one, murdered, would hanging, lethal injection or electric chair be enough. I know it is emotional revenge, but I would want them put to suffering the pain of death.

Over here in the UK we had a nurse that systematically murdered defenceless babies. Should she be allowed to live? Well she is enjoying rent-free accommodation where all her meals are provided for her (see link below). Is this right? I say not.

Supporting Links

Rss RSS