Are religious boycotts getting excessive and ridiculous ?

Certain religious groups boycott Halloween and certain movies claiming that these they portray evil teachings. Examples are "Harry Potter" and the "Golden Compass". The general public thinks that their claims are far fetched, are they?

Posted By Alice on January 2, 2008

You can subscribe to this Debate if you log in.

About Alice

Alice

I think that these religions need to spend time on teaching, and not b!t...

Posted By Alice on January 2, 2008

Call For Backup

Invite others to join and support you in this debate. Or maybe you just want to pick a fight! Either way...

Call for backup now!

These religions are taking things too far and are seeing evil where it doesn't exist.

Alice

I think that these religions need to spend time on teaching, and not b!tching!

-- Posted By Alice on January 2, 2008

These religious groups (mostly Christian) boycott Halloween, and certain movies (Harry Potter, the "Golden Compass", etc) fearing that their influence will deter their children's minds from their parent's religion. They claim that these movies and Halloween are of the devil, or that they undermine Christian views and teachings. I think they are full of it, and that they are more scared than anything else. How can anyone really even listen to their ranting? Do they even have any credibility at ALL to their allegations?

Update:
Concerning the Harry Potter books and movies I'm very dumbfounded as to why our good Christian communities are having a fit ranting that the Harry Potter event is "of the devil" and teaches evil things. Last I saw and heard there was plenty of friendship, love, courage, good triumphing over evil, etc in these films. So whats the big deal that someone can fly on a broomstick, or gets their hand chopped off? What about the "Golden Compass"? I thought that the movies was GREAT and I saw NO evidents of God hate or anti God anything. It hinted at some corrupt church organization, but in life that is a truth you will see in MANY churches ranging from pedophilia to more complicated and darker matters. I think that ridiculous for any religious group get worked up over that particular movie, It too has good teachings for ANY child.
Update:
On top of this did you know that Halloween originally was in CELEBRATION of the banishment of demons and devils from the world? Now how then can you call such an innocent thing as Trick or Treating demonic? Its all for fun, you extremists really need to calm down and breath, your child isn't going to worship satan just because he or she wants to in some way celebrate Halloween.
I whole heartedly agree. I'm a religious person and I see often in even my own religion people who somehow get into their own self produced crusade on one thing or another and honestly is gets very frustrating to try and dissociate with them.
There are a lot of people worked up over the recent "Golden Compass" Movie. I think that they are overreacting even though the author is an atheist and has states that he plans to make a big voice on the matter. I still think that good values can be learned in this series.
I think we are being too polite here. My opinion is that these Religious groups should SHUT THEIR FUC%ING mouths and STOP pushing their views onto others and onto our news headlines. Their crap is EVERYWHERE. Why aren't they making a bigger stink about more pressing issues like rape, drugs, and poverty? I doubt Christ or ANY other religious figure would be making anywhere near as an embarrassing public appearance as these groups are.
Add Comment

These religions are well within their rights to "protect" themselves in anyway they seem fit.

Rss RSS