Polygamy

Is Polygamy morally wrong, or just culturally unacceptable?

Here in the US many think of polygamy as a perverse thing, mostly associated with Mormons. It’s looked at as a disgusting thing. However in other parts of the world relationships are much different than in the US. There can be more men than the

Posted By Radkhat on November 1, 2007

You can subscribe to this Debate if you log in.

About Radkhat

Top Enemies: none
From_the_east

Having more than one wife is preventing anyone in that relationship to h...

Posted By eastwind on November 6, 2007

L_684f116ceb600ffaf044e0afa7831b0f

Polygamy is not always completely voluntary

Posted By jhall85 on November 12, 2007

Tiger_yawn_teeth_bite

People who practice polygamy believe that there is no wrong doing in hav...

Posted By Radkhat on November 1, 2007

Call For Backup

Invite others to join and support you in this debate. Or maybe you just want to pick a fight! Either way...

Call for backup now!

Polygamy is a lifestyle that shouldn’t be judged as a vile thing.

N1251707010_30210200_3493

I plead indifference.

-- Posted By iverson92 on August 12, 2009

Morals are based on society. You learned your morals from society, therefore both sides are equal. It should be whether or not you believe in polygamy. It of course is socially unacceptable, but i do believe that people can do what they want. Its not as if i believe in favor of being married to multiple "beings" or not, it is that i believe that people should be able to do what they want as long as the marriages are mutually agreed upon.

Person_60

I am a woman and I would LOVE two husbands instead of one

-- Posted By arrow2fast on April 21, 2009

Well, I am a mature woman and I would like to find an additional husband!

My (only) husband is overworked and feels that all three could be better of by sharing the chores and life. There are no children involved (all adult) and the only problem is finding the right guy - somebody whose agenda is something else than swinging or bisexuality.

Clearly, there would be no slavery, pedophilia or other problems typically present in the LSD settings since we would be consenting adults caring about each other.

Tiger_yawn_teeth_bite

People who practice polygamy believe that there is no wrong doing in having multiple spouses.

-- Posted By Radkhat on November 1, 2007

There are people who are HAPPY that they are in a multiple spouse relationship. Some find it disgusting. Its good to overcome the anxiety..

It's about a person's free will. How he chooses to live his life is his discretion. As long as he is not cheating on his wife (wives), polygamy is as good as monogamy.
For something to be immoral, someone has to be harmed. There is nothing inherently harmful about polygamy. People can make any kind of relationship harmful. It's all about how they treat each other. Societal norms are usually about protecting property and go all the way back to tribal life. They are just outmoded hangups now.
Add Comment

Polygamy is just a man’s excuse to name his wives “Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, etc”.

2b

Does God approve of polygamy?

-- Posted By Felix on February 23, 2009

Deuteronomy 21:15-16

If a man has two wives, and he loves one but not the other, and both bear him sons but the firstborn is the son of the wife he does not love, when he wills his property to his sons, he must not give the rights of the firstborn to the son of the wife he loves in preference to his actual firstborn, the son of the wife he does not love.

2 Samuel 5:13 (also 1 Ki 11:3)

After he left Hebron, David took more concubines and wives in Jerusalem, and more sons and daughters were born to him.

1 Timothy 3:12 (also 1 Tim 3:2, Titus 1:6)

A deacon must be the husband of but one wife and must manage his children and his household well.

Some points to keep in mind:

* The recording of historical acts, including instances of polygamy, is not necessarily an endorsement of it by God. The Bible records both good and bad actions of people, even people considered to be righteous. The fact that David and Solomon had several wives and that it's in the Bible doesn't automatically imply that God was pleased by it, any more than the records of David's adultery and the arguments in the early church implies God's approval of either.

* Monogamy is first mentioned in Genesis 2:24 - it was God's intention from the beginning. While God did allow polygamy for a time, it was probably for the same reason as his allowance of divorce: "Moses permitted you to divorce your wives because your hearts were hard. But it was not this way from the beginning" (Mt 19:8).

* Rampant polygamy (and possibly all polygamy) was prohibited for kings, because it would cause them to turn from God (Dt 17:17). The Israelites should have reasoned that if this were true for kings, it would be true for others, hence polygamy was something they ought to avoid.

Person_60

Poor society

-- Posted By gforce55x on September 12, 2008

People love sex so much that they would back it up with religious doctrine. How sad.

From_the_east

Having more than one wife is preventing anyone in that relationship to have a GREAT relationship.

-- Posted By eastwind on November 6, 2007

When a marriage consists of just one wife and one husband it is able to grow richer. You get to know that ONE person very well over the years. Sharing many becomes a problem. Plus, with all of the possible problems in marriage why multiply them?

L_684f116ceb600ffaf044e0afa7831b0f

Polygamy is not always completely voluntary

-- Posted By jhall85 on November 12, 2007

There are cases of some girls getting caught up with groups of polygamists against their will. Many of these people operate like cults and i think some vulnerable people are tricked into getting involved.

True, there are a lot of things ABOUT that life style that are off.
Add Comment
4922

Polygamy is unfair on women

-- Posted By colander on December 20, 2007

It's interesting how it's the men who are allowed multiple wives, but are women allowed multiple husbands?

4922

Polygamy is unfair on women

-- Posted By colander on December 20, 2007

It's interesting how it's the men who are allowed multiple wives, but are women allowed multiple husbands?

Peejay

It is child sexual slavery...don't miss the point

-- Posted By PeeJay on April 8, 2008

There are many out there who do not live close to the source, as some I know do. The polygamy problem is just now being recognized in the national spotlight due to the issues in Texas, and the recent trial of Warren Jeffs. These old men are committing crimes on children, and trying to get away with it.

What if two women WANT to share one man in marriage? Or if one WOMAN wants TWO husbands and both of those men are OK with that?

There is nothing wrong with consensual adults do what they want with each other when it hurts no one else.

Well, I am a mature woman and I would like to find an additional husband!
My (only) husband is overworked and feels that all three could be better of by sharing the chores and life. There are no children involved (all adult) and the only problem is finding the right guy - somebody whose agenda is something else than swinging or bisexuality.
Clearly, there would be no slavery, pedophilia or other problems typically present in the LSD settings since we would be consenting adults caring about each other.
Add Comment
Person_60

Let's look at polygamy

-- Posted By emmmapeel82 on August 15, 2008

Let's look at the circumstances polygamy occurs under these days. They are usually in very sheltered communities that discourage or outright ban any outside influences.

True the people involved will say they are protecting themselves and their children but I think that whenever someone will not let their child even see a different way of life from their own, deep down they know their child will choose the alternative and the alternative is probably in their best interest.

If you have to lie about and hide a lifestyle from children, it's time to examine your own very carefully.

Rss RSS