Is College Really Necessary Anymore?
I want to see what everyone thinks on this topic, because I feel that things have greatly changed in recent years.
Posted By Jordan on July 23, 2007
I believe College is overrated.
Posted By allenamandamarie on October 24, 2008
I find myself offended with your statement.
Posted By BigMACK on September 9, 2007
Odds of success in a career favor those who finish, or at least go to co...
Posted By ClamMan on July 23, 2007
Its all about how lazy you are, not your formal education.
Posted By eastwind on November 6, 2007
College is not even close to necessary anymore.
There are more and more people becoming very successful without college.
-- Posted By Jordan on July 23, 2007College ties you down to one skillset, and most likely working for someone. Becoming and entrepreneur has become a lot more popular because of the freedom if carries with it.
Let's not assume that everyone WANTS to be an entrepreneur. There are many people that like and thrive in a corporate environment. For them, college is VERY necessary. . This argument should be in the other column.
Not all college graduates are successful.
The market place is no longer a level playing field. Gone are the days where you attend 4 years of college, get a great job, and skate through life. Most jobs that once required a Bachelors Degree now require a
Obviously you can still be a very successful entrepreneur with a college degree, but its definitely not necessary, and some (including myself) see it as a waste of time.
This is clearly an issue of preference. I strongly believe that it is not required in life to have a college education to become successful. I saw that someone said that it greatly boosts your odds if you DO have an education. I have seen many who fail
While you can learn a ton attending college most do it for the wrong reason and never use 98% of everything they "learn". I had the comment from an attendee at my recent workshop that they got more from 3 days than their 4 year degree.
At my last job I was an Administrative Services Coordinator. Basically that meant that I corrected and redid all the subpar work that the credentialed people had done. I also was in charge of creating and providing training to teach them how to perform their jobs correctly. I have no degree. The only difference between them and me was my superior intelligence and their superior wages.
Its all about how lazy you are, not your formal education.
-- Posted By eastwind on November 6, 2007Education in any setting should be because the individual wants to learn that topic specifically for a specific purpose. Much in College is useless to the majority of attending students. Education to me is enjoyable and so I'm enrolled. .
College is an over-glorified assembly of educators trying to make a profit, not teach you anything.
-- Posted By Jake_the_Mad on September 12, 2007I've been to college. I possess a doctorate in cultural anthropology, emphasis on social psychology therein and thereof. I learned nothing that I could not have acquired myself with the books, materials and sound strategy. In fact, if I had taught myself, I would not have been limited by the curriculum. If I had been presented with a guideline rather than a dictated array of boxed coursework, I'd be far better off than I am now. So, after seven years of education, my actual, valuable education begins now, with me at the helm, not a professor or doctoral board of administrators.
College is a business out to make a profit. The product is an occasionally solid, sometimes useful accreditation in the form of a piece of paper that essentially says "you learned something". . As it happens, you don't always need to know anything to walk off with a degree. The quality of your education depends on the quality of your educators as well as your stick-to-it-ivness. As I see it, there is nothing taught in a college that could not be learned on-the-job in a quarter of the time (or less). Jobs aren't guaranteed to college graduates, nor are college graduates necessarily more able to do the jobs they find.
Great point. Besides, just because someone is good at school does not necessarily mean they are intelligent or competent. Most of the morons i knew in high school have degrees and are still dumb and unsuccessful.
Many college grads are working minimum wage jobs because the marketplace is flooded with degrees.
-- Posted By themonk on September 10, 2007A highly competitive job market and a flood of people with degrees means there are hundreds of applicants for every "good" job. A trade school diploma or specialize training is more valuable. tjgjllnj. fhjf.
I know several recent grads who have to resort to minimum wage jobs. I am in the same boat, and hoping to find something until I hit grad school. Maybe then my degree will be worth something.
I'm doing 4 year degree n this placement year, I couldn't find any place as they got experienced students. & i'm still working in small restaurant from past 3 years as all jobs I apply 4 never reply. so degree doesn't count at all. its just a name.
Pick a new major.. This argument should be in the other column.
Many employers hold 4 years of experience way above a 4 year degree. For example, instead of getting a journalism degree, you can bust your ass and get published on freelance.
It's not even that it's filled with degrees. The company is looking out for the bottom line and their shareholders. A degree means they have to pay someone more. No degree means they make a profit still.
There are times when you will find a highly qualified person working as a waiter in a restaurant. So no, it is not necessary for a person to attend college in order to be successful. .
I agree with you. I'm just doing that. .
With a good knowledge of the business that you want to go into and a good portfolio, you can easily shave 8 years off of the prep time needed to get a good job.
The portfolio proves experience which college can't provide. And in the course of building it (freelance if necessary), you'll learn the real-world things that college can't teach.
It helps if you can negotiate a 'trial run' as a contractor, and excel at the project that determines whether or not you get hired.
It also really helps if you know someone on the inside. They can both give you the knowledge of what you _really_ need to know (vs what college would teach) and explain to others what you can do (when you don't have a degree to show it).
College is valuable, but not absolutely necessary. An understanding of the business beyond just your job duties is absolutely necessary, as is the ability to prove that you can do those job duties.
That said, you may still have a difficult time without a degree, but you'll be better off when you succeed than someone with a degree who can't do their job (or worse, someone with a degree who can't get the job).
College is the only way you'll ever make a good living and/or be a good person.
Succesful College Graduates is a self-fulfilling prophecy.
-- Posted By Hacbarton on September 10, 2007Usually, people who go to college and finish are above the fray anyway, so the fact that they succeed in the working world is skewed. Its a matter of false causation.
Most jobs will only hire applicants who have a degree, whether or not it correlates to the job.
-- Posted By lindsayloo14 on September 11, 2007Whether or not you believe that a college degree is necessary, it's the way of the world. Most good jobs require you to hold at least an Associates degree, whether it's in the same field as your job or not.
I honestly don't feel it is necessary anymore. I have a Doctorates in IT Security and two masters, one is in Oceanography and the other is in Business Management. I am still unable to follow my career as I am often told that I am "overqualified".
College is important not just for studies in your major but in overall broadening of horizons.
-- Posted By Perdie on September 18, 2007There may be difficulties in hiring at entry level, but a good college education will provide an outlook that can help move you up the ladders later on. .
How dare you say that people are only good if they go to college and only make good money if they are educated! Are you really that clueless?
If you know you do not have the drive, motivation and work ethic to run a business, go to college.
-- Posted By visionary1 on September 10, 2007True success can only be achieved working for yourself. If you do not have the vision to do that accept that you will always be less than you could have been. College is for the mediocraty.
Nothing in life is a given. College often perpetuates the false assumption that an "A" grade will get you that "A" life. I've met too many college graduates who can't cook themselves a meal.
Supporting Links
Critical thinking and simple reading comprehension is atrocious at the High school level
-- Posted By Zarathustra on September 10, 2007Let's not beat around the bush here. I'll be blunt. In my view, having just recently graduated high school and entered college, high school students, in general, are very ignorant. Not necessarily stupid, but ignorant. Ignorance is not strength.
College gives you an much needed advantage in the work force. Yeah, you can get a job and maybe
-- Posted By Rocky-Mt-High on September 13, 2007become incredibly successful but the odds are against you. .
I think a higher level of education is the only way you will get a job.
-- Posted By sirenavs on July 24, 2007It seems today that even the most base job requires some form of post secondary job. If you expect to find a job you need a degree in something. The higher your post secondary degree is the greater your chance of landing a well paying career. Without some
Why would anyone want a Job? Education is vital to your success, just not neccessarily a colllege education. There are countless HS dropout that are very successfull.
This is a test to see how long of a paragraph I can insert without it truncating. This is a test to see how long of a paragraph I can insert without it truncating. This is a test to see how long of a paragraph I can insert wittout it truncating trun.
The odds of a new business lasting more than a year are not very good. While successful entrepreneurs do very well, usually better than employees, unsuccessful ones fail by definition and either go on to their next experiment or go to work for someone el
Odds of success in a career favor those who finish, or at least go to college.
-- Posted By ClamMan on July 23, 2007I dont think that going to college makes you a better person. But I do think it gives you certain advantages. Those who attend college, and finish gain certain discipline and habits that will aid in success no matter what field they go into.
The most important aspect of education enhancing one's career development is to ensure that you study a course of knowledge which inspires and unleashes your passion(s) otherwise it may be useful, but not in such a way that makes you clearly shine.
The advantages of formal study to advance your career are then clearly evident, as not only do you excell in your chosen field, but you also have the combination of magic ingredients that will make you a winner: education, passion and drive!
Bill Gates Drops out of Harvard. His success suffers! Sounds like a great headline.
There are very few Bill Gates on this earth. Most financially successful people have a degree or two or three. . If you look at statistics, the overwhelming number of successful people have college educations. .

Digg
Delicious
Reddit
Yahoo
Google
Stumbleupon
RSS
About Jordan
I'm a highly distracted entrepreneur that enjoys gadgets, reading, and everything about new technology.